About The Inn

Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the Inn houses 8 newly-renovated guest rooms. All of the accommodations offer private baths, and they are all furnished with period pieces. The Inn boasts a beautiful collection of antique beds found in remote areas from western Pennsylvania up to the northern corners of Maine. One of our favorite headboards was originally an old iron estate gate craftily converted into a four-postered queensized bed. Many rooms offer private harborfront balconies presenting fabulous views of the Atlantic Ocean, Crescent Beach and Ballard’s Beach, as well as the northern neck of the Island.

Our warm and personable staff is always ready to greet you each morning with a smile. Guests congregate at 5pm in our ferry-facing lounge to enjoy our complimentary wine & cheese hour, offered in July and August. Whether chatting with friends in the guest parlor, enjoying a cool drink on the wraparound veranda, or relaxing in our airy harbor-front lounge, the atmosphere of being among friends is readily apparent. If you are looking for that perfect seaside getaway, please join us!

Kai-Kai Sandal on The Deck

Since 2003, sandal fanatics have cherished Kai’s Pure Comfort creation: the Kai-Kai Sandal. Try one on while you are enjoying the view of Old Harbor on our back deck. Kai-Kai Sandals offer excellent arch support and a comfortable suede footbed. The soles are made of incredibly durable and long lasting Brazilian rubber, which is why you can “Swap Your Flop” …. ask for details! And visit our flagship stores in Key West & Montauk, NY.

Block Island Ice Cream

Serving 16 locally made flavors, iced coffee, cold refreshments, and candy. A delicious stop as you arrive on BI or during your stay!

info@innatoldharbor.com | Call us (914) 707-3367